Letters to the Editor
To the Editors:
After reading “Model Stock Portfolio: Beating the Benchmark Is Nice, But a Loss Isn’t,” in the April 2009 AAII Journal, I think there are some errors in Figure 1. In particular, I think the three-year risk-adjusted return is wrong. As I understand it, the RiskGrade is higher for higher risk. If that is the case, then the risk-adjusted return for the Shadow Stock portfolio and the Vanguard Small Cap Index fund should be worse than unadjusted, not better! (For some reason, the risk-adjusted return for the Vanguard 500 Index fund was correctly calculated.)
This is frequently a problem with formulas that assume positive returns. When the returns are positive, everything works correctly but when they are negative, the formula must be modified. As a result, the risk-adjusted three-year return for the Shadow Stock portfolio would be –31.1%. Not a pretty picture!
...To continue reading this article you must be registered with AAII.
Already registered with AAII? Login to read the rest of this article.
to read this article and receive access to future AAII.com articles.