- Election of Directors: Will the independent directors (non-management) effectively represent the outside shareholders (i.e., you)? How much stock do they own? Are their interests aligned with yours? Do inside directors (management) have seats (votes) commensurate with their share ownership?
- Executive Compensation and Stock Ownership: By law, companies must disclose, for the last three years, how much key insiders earn, including salary, bonuses, restricted stock, retirement plan contributions and options. Is the management teams compensation commensurate with company performance? If the combined executive compensation marches continually upward while earnings go sideways or down, Ill normally pass on owning the shares.
- Related Party Transactions: This is normally buried toward the back of the proxy, for good reason. It highlights transactions and relationships that, while not illegal, should be examined carefully for unethical behavior. All of the above are usually disclosed in the Proxy for Annual Shareholders Meeting. However, shareholders are often asked to vote at special shareholder meetings held to approve a specific transaction such as a merger, acquisition, or spin-off. These documents are often voluminous, but they contain key information.
- Form 3: Initial report of holdings filed within 10 days of achieving insider status.
- Form 4: Insider purchases or sales of shares within two business days of transaction.
- Form 5: Year-end report of holdings filed within 45 days of a firms year-end.
- Form 144: Intention to sell. Must be filed by anyone intending to sell restricted, unregistered securitiesusually provided as part of an executives compensation.
Navigating Through EDGAR: What to Look for on the SEC Web Site
by John Deysher
As a portfolio manager, one of my favorite Web sites is the SECs www.sec.gov. Theres a wealth of information here and its all free. In a world full of marginal financial sites, this one stands out.
While the site covers a lot of ground, the section most relevant to individual investors is Filings and Forms, better known as EDGAR.
EDGAR stands for electronic data gathering and retrieval. The SEC requires all entities offering securities to the general public to make periodic filings to the SEC electronically, through EDGAR.
This is the portion of the site I use most frequentlyespecially the Search for Company Filings function, which allows you to type in a companys name and see all the filings for the last 10 years.
What, in particular, should you look for? Key filings to be aware of include:
This is the annual report every public firm files with the SEC within 75 days of the firms year-end. If you want a clear and concise report on what a company does and how its faring, this is it. Key information usually not included in the Annual Report to Shareholders is found here, including: competitors, channels of distribution, head count, concentration of customers, marketing initiatives, manufacturing infrastructure, litigation, and important business trends.
This is the quarterly report every company files within 45 days of its quarter-end, with more detail than quarterly reports to shareholders.
This is the disclosure of a non-recurring material event, such as a merger, acquisition, sale of a division, bankruptcy, executive resignation or litigation.
Form DEF 14A: Proxy Statement, Notification of Shareholder Meeting
Usually this is filed for the annual meeting and contains reams of information. In this document, you should focus on:
All companies issuing new shares to the publicwhether initial public offering (IPO) or secondary offeringmust file disclosure statements with the SEC detailing the business and its prospects. For an IPO like Google, this provides an important look at what makes a company tick and its investment merits. While I rarely invest in IPOs (theyre often overpriced), I will always read those of companies that compete with existing holdings. Theres often disclosure about the industry and trends you cant find elsewhere.
A company must also file a Registration Statement for a secondary offering of new or existing (insider) shares. These are also worth reading, as theres usually additional disclosures not found in a companys 10-K or 10-Q filings.
Note: When a company spins off a new company, details are usually disclosed in a Form 10 filed by the existing company. For example, the imminent spin-off of Viads Moneygram unit is disclosed in the Form 10 filed by Viad.
Forms 3, 4, 5 and 144 These are insider (key management/directors) ownership filings:
Forms 13D, 13G, 13F
These filings detail the holdings of major investors, institutional or individual. They provide a glimpse of what the smart money is doing.
Form 13D: Any entity acquiring 5% or greater of a stocks outstanding shares with intent to exert influence or control (an activist investor) must make this filing within 10 calendar days of hitting the 5% threshold. The filing must detail the reason for the accumulation, the number of shares purchased and price paid, and any subsequent changes to the holding (up or down) in 1% increments. There are many activist investors these days, and knowing their targets can be an effective money-making technique.
Form 13G: Similar to 13D, this is filed by any entity acquiring 5% or greater of outstanding shares with no intent to exert influence or control (a passive investor), and it must be filed within 45 days of the calendar year-end beginning with the end of the year in which the 5% threshold is crossed. If the stake is at least 10%, the investor must file a 13G within 10 days after the end of the month in which the 10% threshold was crossed. Sometimes, investors who file 13Gs initially decide to turn up the heat on management and convert to 13D, triggering a rise in the share price.
Form 13F: Required to be filed by all money managers and investment advisers with at least $100 million under management within 45 days of the calendar quarter-end. The filing details the companies and shares owned (you must figure out from prior filings what changes there were in the portfolio). Want to see what Warren Buffett did in a particular quarter? Just click on the 13F filed by Berkshire Hathaway Inc. or Berkshire Hathaway Life Insurance Co.
This should get you started, but there are other parts of the site that are useful so make sure to browse around. Remember, your tax dollars help pay for this site, and theres lots of good information here, so put it to good use.
John E. Deysher is president and portfolio manager of the Pinnacle Value Fund, a diversified, SEC-registered, open-end mutual fund specializing in the securities of small and micro-cap companies. He is a Chartered Financial Analyst (CFA) and has been managing equity portfolios for over 20 years. He lives and works in New York City. He may be reached at email@example.com