Offbeat Offerings: Mortgage-Backed Securities
The current housing market decline, increasing mortgage defaults and the financial struggles at Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac have shined a spotlight on a particular fixed-income product that is often not particularly well-understood by individual investors—mortgage-backed securities.
What are these products?
Mortgage-backed securities are bonds that are backed by a pool of home mortgages. Investors receive proportionate shares of the interest and principal generated by the underlying mortgages. Typically the timely payment of both interest and principal is guaranteed, even if the home-owner defaults, by either the U.S. government through the Government National Mortgage Association (Ginnie Mae), or by one of two government-sponsored organizations, the Federal National Mortgage Association (Fannie Mae) or the Federal Home Loan Mortgage Association (Freddie Mac). The securities tend to be traded in large denominations; individual investors typically invest in these products through mutual funds or exchange-traded funds.
Their primary advantage is higher yields than other fixed-income instruments of comparable stated maturity and credit risk. However, those higher yields reflect risks that are different from those of other high-quality fixed-income securities.
The process of creating these securities can be very complex. A mortgage lender pools together similar mortgages and sells them, typically to one of the insuring agencies (Ginnie Mae, Fannie Mae or Freddie Mac). While the lender retains responsibility for servicing the mortgages, the mortgage pools are “securitized” (securities are issued that represent fractional undivided interests in the pool) and sold to securities dealers, who then sell the securities to investors. The lender collects monthly payments of principal and interest and forwards it to the insuring agency, which then passes on the payments to investors whether or not payment has been received from the homebuyer.
Like bonds, mortgage-backed securities pay a coupon rate of interest. Unlike bonds, however, the principal is repaid in increments over the life of the security, as the underlying mortgage loans are paid off, rather than in a single lump sum at maturity.
Because homeowners can pay off their mortgages early through refinancings, or when they sell their homes, the monthly payment amounts (consisting of both interest and principal) to investors can be irregular due to prepayments. When any prepayments occur the payments are distributed to the security holders on a pro rata basis.
Unlike bonds, which are traded based on their maturity date, mortgage-backed securities are traded based on their “average life”—the average amount of time that will elapse from the date of purchase until the entire principal amount is repaid, which takes into account an assumed prepayment forecast.
There are many different types of mortgage-backed securities. The most common type of mortgage-backed security is called a pass-through or participation certificate. The dealer of the security collects the monthly payments from homeowners and passes it through to the investors.
Most of these securities are issued by or guaranteed by Ginnie Mae, Fannie Mae or Freddie Mac and carry an implied AAA or AA credit rating. The payments are considered secure but can vary in amount from month to month due to prepayments from homeowners. Most pass-through securities are backed by fixed-rate mortgages. However, pass-through securities backed by adjustable-rate mortgages are also available. The stated maturity on pass-through securities is typically 30 years, although shorter-term stated maturities are also available; however, actual maturities will be substantially shorter to the extent that homeowners pay off loans prematurely.
Most mortgage securities are issued or guaranteed by Ginnie Mae, Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac. A number of private investment institutions repackage these securities for sale as well. Investors can buy the securities directly from the issuer or on the secondary markets. However, most investors that directly invest in these products are institutions. Individual investors typically invest in the products through mutual funds or exchange-traded funds.
Mortgage-backed securities are fixed-income securities, but because the payments can be irregular, they are not for investors who need to count on a steady stream of income. Yields can be higher than traditional bonds of similar maturity and credit risk, but other risks are also higher. Due to the complexity of the product, individuals interested in these products should invest in them through mutual funds.
Investors in mortgage securities are subject to tax on both the coupon payments and any return on the principal purchase amount. If the security was sold at a discount from face value, the investor is taxed on the additional return over the life of the security.
Both cash interest payments and increase in principal value are reported on Form 1099-INT or Form 1099-OID, which are issued to investors each year.
Yields on mortgage-backed securities are typically higher than other fixed-income investments of similar credit quality and similar stated maturity.
Lower Credit Risk
Any of the securities that are issued or guaranteed by Ginnie Mae are fully backed by the U.S. government.
Securities guaranteed by Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac are not backed by the full faith and credit of the U.S. government, but both agencies have a line of credit to the U.S. Treasury, and in the past the credit markets have considered the securities to be essentially equivalent to those issued by U.S. government-backed agencies. In mid-July, when massive debt and income shortfalls were reported by both government-sponsored agencies, Congress stepped in and opened a line of credit to Freddie Mac and Fannie Mae that is estimated to top $300 billion if necessary. However, the current financial condition of the agencies themselves remains shaky.
Interest Rate Risk
As with all fixed-income securities, the value of existing mortgage-backed securities will fluctuate with interest rates movements; falling rates usually result in higher values and rising rates generally result in lower values, with longer-term securities fluctuating to a greater degree than shorter-term securities.
Maturity Risk and Reinvestment Rate Risk
Interest rate changes may affect decisions by homeowners in the underlying mortgages, which will affect the rate at which principal payments are returned over the life of the security. For that reason, the actual maturity of a mortgage-backed security is uncertain, and may be much shorter than expected, or longer than anticipated. When interest rates decline, prepayments usually increase as homeowners refinance at lower rates; if prepayments are higher than expected, the actual maturity of the security is decreased and investors will receive the entirety of the principal earlier than expected, forcing them to reinvest their money at a lower rate than they thought they would receive when they originally invested in the security. When interest rates increase, mortgage prepayments typically slow, and investors will receive principal payments more slowly than expected, missing out on a higher rate as they wait for their investment to mature.
Inaccurate Yield Calculations
The yield calculation for mortgage-backed securities is based on a number of factors, including assumptions concerning prepayment of mortgages. If these predictions and assumptions prove to be inaccurate, the actual yield will differ from the stated yield.
InvestinginBonds.com was created by The Securities Industry and Financial Markets Association to help educate bond investors. The site has information for beginning and advanced investors. The site includes educational articles, investing tips, bond price information and market data, and news and commentary. The site is free.