The Financial Advice Gap

Many individual investors currently going without financial advice might realize greater wealth if they took advantage of financial advice.

 

Many individual investors currently going without financial advice might realize greater wealth if they took advantage of financial advice.

The International Longevity Centre U.K. (ILC), a self-described think tank on longevity, conducted a study that divided its participants into two groups: those who received financial advice and those who did not. Researchers then framed respondents into ‘affluent’ and ‘just getting by’ groups for purposes of analysis. In order to see how the group that didn’t receive financial advice would fare if they had received advice, the researchers focused on five different categories of income: accumulated pension wealth, net financial wealth, occupational pension income, the probability of saving income between 2014 and 2016 and the probability of owning equity assets.

For each of the five categories, the study found that certain incomes were more monetarily affected by financial advice than others. Considering pension wealth, the benefit of financial advice was higher for the just getting by group and lower for the affluent group. For financial assets, financial advice had more of an impact on the affluent group. Financial advice for occupational pension income had a slightly larger effect for the affluent group than the just getting by group (increases of 50% and 40%, respectively). When it comes to the probability of investors having savings, the addition of financial advice increases the odds by 4.1 percentage points. However, the study found that financial advice can also increase the probability of investors having risky assets by 7.5 percentage points.

The study found that the total value of financial advice is about $62,900. For the investors receiving financial advice, their primary sources for that advice included: independent financial advisers, banks, other professionals, free services, work/family and other. The study’s authors explained that nearly nine out of 10 investors who received financial advice had an independent financial adviser or bank as their primary source.

In conclusion, the study suggests that advisers communicate clearly about the costs and benefits of advice and harness technology to ensure high-quality advice and tools are available to those who do not receive professional advice.

Source: “What It’s Worth: Revisiting the Value of Financial Advice,” by Brian Beach; ILC, December 2019.

Discussion

Larry U from CA posted over 6 years ago:

I understand the value of financial advice but at what cost to the client. How much does the cost of advice information vs. the amount of $62,900 advice value compare?


John Lambert from NJ posted over 6 years ago:

This study appears to prove that if you tell people to save more("good financial advice"); they will save more and retire with more money. The self motivated could easily accomplish this without paying an Advisor for "good financial advice". Let's assume your advisor receives 1% of your assets / year as a fee for his advice and you want to save $1.0 million for retirement. Your average annual asset balance is $500,000 and you have 30 years till retirement. Your advisor is going to receive $150,000 for his advice. This is not a good trade off against the cost of AAII membership and the time and cost to educate yourself.


John McKeon from Vermont posted over 6 years ago:

In response to John from NJ. I'm not a financial advisor, nor have I engaged with one until just last year. I needed to invest $100,000 to use in retirement. I'm certain I could easily have found an investment vehicle out there to put this money but I'm just as easily convinced I could lose all or most of it just like that. In your scenario of starting at $500,000 and ending with $1,000,000 I would be a wreck worrying about doing the right thing. When working with large amounts of money, I would recommend a professional. I would want to make sure he knew his stuff of course and was comfortable with his investment advice. Understand I'm not all that educated in investing. You may be much more educated in this than I. I only comment on this because there are probably more people like me out there that would be better off with an advisor than doing it on their own.


You need to log in as a registered AAII user before commenting.
Create an account

Log In

Get your free copy of our special report analyzing the tech stocks most likely to outperform the market.

Download the FREE Report Here: