The Benefits and Costs of Long-Term Care Insurance

A little bit of insurance coverage for long-term care could make a big difference for your entire family. And now there’s a new policy type worth considering.

Long-term care (LTC) insurance is an essential part of your financial plan at any age. In the past few years, new types of policies have created more realistically priced, guaranteed benefits to guard against impoverishment from the need for help doing basic activities of daily living.

Many LTC policy-owners who bought insurance years ago have found their premiums rising as insurers recalculated longevity. The good news now is that the industry has moved to a newer type of policy, which removes the threat of rising premiums and does guarantee coverage for care.

It’s called a “hybrid asset-based” or “combo” policy, in which you make a one-time deposit (or a series of premium payments) into a life insurance policy. That policy offers a long-term care insurance rider—which means you leverage your money to pay for long-term care—for one or two lives. And if the care isn’t needed, your beneficiaries get a death benefit, less any claims paid out.

Why You Should Consider Buying LTC Insurance

You don’t want to be a burden on your adult children—and you don’t want to be in a state-funded nursing home. We all hope to live to a healthy old age, and then die peacefully in our sleep. But the facts say that once over age 65, chances are greater that you’ll need some help doing basic activities of daily living (showering, toileting, transferring from bed to chair, feeding yourself) than the odds of your house burning down. Yet, you still pay for homeowner’s insurance.

You should worry about accessing care, whether you are alone or have adult children. The baby boomer generation is living longer, healthier lives. But sooner or later, time will catch up. It’s estimated that seven out of 10 people over age 65 today will need some long-term care, and one of five will need more than five years of care.

And if you’re thinking that Medicare will pay, think again. Medicare pays only for a limited number of days of skilled nursing, and only after a hospital stay. Your state-funded Medicaid program will provide care if you run out of money—but only in a facility that is likely not going to be your choice of care.

(And states are getting aggressive about finding assets that have been transferred to create impoverishment and eligibility for state-paid nursing home care.)

Here are the issues your adult children would face if you don’t have insurance to pay for care in your old age: Will you care for your parents—and your in-laws—in their old age? Will you invite them into your home, to use the bedroom your college kid just vacated, and will you provide them with help dressing and bathing?

Or let’s reverse the situation. Here’s what you might be thinking: Who will care for you in your old age? Will your children invite you to live with them and help you shower and take you to your doctors’ appointments?

The time to think about these issues is now—while you can solve for these potential problems by purchasing long-term care insurance.

The Cost of Care

Care is costly, whether given in the home, in assisted living or in a nursing home. Again, the cost of that care is not covered by Medicare (except for a limited number of days in a skilled nursing facility after a hospitalization), or by your Medicare supplement insurance. You, or your family, will have to spend a lot of money to provide that care, and those costs are rising faster than inflation.

For example, according to the latest annual cost of care survey by Genworth Financial, the average private room nursing home now costs $100,375 per year. And assisted-living facilities now cost nearly $48,000 a year, more if you have a cognitive problem.

But those numbers may not reflect the true cost of care. Many will need round-the-clock care, raising the amount spent. There’s also the forgone income lost by family members who provide unpaid care.

Think about how those costs would add up over several years of care. Today, there are 1.8 million Americans residing in skilled nursing facilities and 12% have been there for five years or more.

Having long-term care insurance does more than just pay for your care. It keeps you from spending all your savings, so your spouse or family does not become impoverished. And it gives you the choice of where you want to receive that assistance—at home, in an assisted-living facility or in a private nursing home.

Not everyone can afford to be fully insured for long-term care. But even a small amount of insurance will get you into a private facility, where you may be able to remain if you use up your insurance benefits and require state aid.

Understanding Long-Term Care Insurance

The time to purchase a policy is when you’re healthy and can qualify for the least expensive policy. Most LTC policies require a medical underwriting to determine that you are eligible and to set the price of your coverage.

Given the benefits provided by the newer “combo” life and long-term care policies, you might start considering LTC insurance at age 50 or earlier, when prices will be lower. And you’re not too old to buy a policy at age 70, if you’re still in good health and can afford the premiums. The amount of coverage you can get for your money will be more expensive as you grow older, so don’t procrastinate.

Long-term care insurance is especially important for women. It’s a fact: Women live longer than men. So, you’re likely to wind up on your own. If there was a man in your life at one point, he is likely to have used up the family’s financial resources, as well as your energy in providing care and assistance.

And if you are a woman who expects to be alone in her later years, there’s an added benefit that comes with an LTC insurance policy. Most policies provide a geriatric care manager who not only will help with the payout but will assist you in finding appropriate care providers or settings.

Activities of Daily Living

Activities of daily living (ADLs) are basic actions that those without impairments limiting their ability to function are able to perform on a daily basis. Long-term care policies, and many other programs, use a person’s inability to perform a certain number (e.g., two or more) of these ADLs as a qualification for receiving benefits.

The six ADLs are:

  • Bathing—Includes washing your body and hair as well as getting in or out of a tub or shower
  • Dressing—Putting on or taking off clothing or braces
  • Transferring—The ability to move about, such as getting out of a chair or bed
  • Eating—Consuming food and drink without assistance
  • Toileting—Getting on and off the toilet and cleaning yourself
  • Continence—Maintaining control of bowel and bladder function

Source: AAII.

What Does a Long-Term Care Policy Cover?

Long-term care insurance policies typically cover nonskilled, skilled and custodial care as well as adult day care, either in your home, an assisted-living facility or a nursing home. All policies vary slightly in their coverage, so you will need an insurance agent who is familiar with these products to guide you through the purchase (see below). But here are the basics.

Elimination Period

Just as you have a deductible on your car insurance, there will also be a deductible—called a waiting or elimination period—before your LTC coverage kicks in. Typically, this is a 90- or 100-day period.

Daily or Monthly Benefit

You’ll want to have at least $6,000 a month in coverage. But if that makes the policy too expensive, it’s better to have a smaller amount of coverage to assist with the cost of care than none at all.

Length of Benefit

Your policy could offer benefits for a period from two years to as long as you need care—sometimes called lifetime benefits, which is especially expensive. These days the most popular benefit period is four to five years. The average stay in a nursing home is about three years—although Alzheimer’s and stroke victims could require assistance for a decade or more. So, compare the costs for a range of benefits and time periods.

Inflation Protection

The potential impact of inflation on care costs is a real concern when purchasing long-term care insurance. After all, you hope to use this coverage in the far-distant future, if at all. The best—and most expensive—policies will offer a 3% compound inflation protection.

What Should Traditional Long-Term Care Insurance Cost?

So-called traditional policies require an annual payment or a payment over a set period of years. Obviously, the annual premium on this type of policy will vary depending on the choices you make—working with your knowledgeable LTC specialist. Your age and health make a difference, as well as your state of residence (care costs are higher in some states).

That said, here’s an example of what a traditional (annual premiums) policy might cost at the time of this writing for a 60-year-old woman in good health, residing in Illinois. She decides to purchase a policy that offers five years of coverage, with a 90-day elimination period, at a current daily benefit of $210 per day ($6,300 per month).

The policy includes a 3% compound inflation protection that guarantees her a maximum benefit of $509/day at age 80. By the time she reaches age 80, she would have a total “pool of benefits” of $930,238 if she hasn’t used any benefits. If she starts needing care soon, there is a current guaranteed pool of benefits amounting to $383,250.

If she decides on an annual payment, the current cost will be $4,412 per year. If she decides on a 10-year payment schedule, the initial annual premium is $12,371. And that premium could actually rise during the next nine years of payments.

That is a whopping cost for most 60-year-old women to pay, on either schedule. There are some ways to mitigate those costs.

If she owns her own business, the premiums may be paid pretax, somewhat reducing the impact. Those who have health savings accounts (HSAs) at work can use those dollars toward LTC insurance premiums. Later on, if a person has significant unreimbursed medical expenses (exceeding 10% of adjusted gross income) the premiums for this insurance can be considered part of those potentially deductible costs.

But the costs for this insurance, at first look, are astounding. They are only dwarfed by the potential costs of the care itself.

Adjustments to coverage can reduce premiums. Perhaps the benefit period could be reduced, or other terms be adjusted—perhaps owning just enough benefits to cover entry into a nursing home, which eventually will allow you to remain when benefits run out and Medicaid may take over.

But before you think there is absolutely no way you can afford any long-term care insurance coverage, consider the hybrid or “combo” policies that are becoming far more attractive in the coverage and cost protection they offer.

Combo Life/Long-Term Care Policy Coverage

This is the way I suggest purchasing long-term care insurance today. Combo or hybrid policies remove uncertainties about rising premiums and give guarantees that if the money is not spent on care, your beneficiaries get a death benefit. You can even borrow some money out of your policy (reducing money available for care or the death benefit). It’s easy to understand, and easy to price. And remember, the price you’re paying is the price of peace of mind.

Here’s how these policies work: You deposit a lump sum of money into the policy. You can do that at all at once, or in a series of guaranteed payments lasting five, 10 or 20 years. Obviously, the longer you stretch out the payments, the more you ultimately pay.

You are purchasing a guaranteed whole life insurance policy with a long-term care rider. The entire death benefit can be accessed as monthly LTC insurance benefits. The policy accumulates a monthly benefit for long-term care. Any unused benefits pass to your policy beneficiaries in the form of a life insurance death benefit. If a person uses the entire death benefit for care, some carriers will still provide a residual death benefit.

The Two Criteria for Receiving Long-Term Care Insurance Benefits

Receiving benefits from long-term care insurance requires meeting two criteria: the benefit trigger and the elimination period.

Benefit Triggers

Benefit triggers are the criteria that an insurance company will use to determine if you are eligible for benefits. Most companies use a specific assessment form that will be filled out by a nurse/social worker team. Benefit triggers are:

  • The criteria insurance policies use to determine if you are eligible for long-term care benefits,
  • Determined through a company-sponsored nurse/social worker assessment of your condition,
  • Usually defined in terms of activities of daily living (ADLs) or cognitive impairments, and
  • Defined for most policies as needing help with two or more of the six ADLs or having a cognitive impairment.

Once you have been assessed, your care manager from the insurance company will approve a plan of care that outlines the benefits for which you are eligible.

Elimination Period

  • The elimination period is the amount of time that must pass after a benefit trigger occurs but before you start receiving payment for services.
  • An elimination period is like the deductible you have on car insurance, except it is measured in time rather than by dollar amount.
  • Most policies allow you to choose an elimination period of 30 days, 60 days or 90 days at the time you purchase your policy.
  • During the elimination period, you must cover the cost of any services you receive.
  • Some policies specify that in order to satisfy an elimination period, you must receive paid care or pay for services during that time.

Source: LongTermCare.gov.

Pricing a Combo Policy

A combo policy has a one-time “premium” (or it can be structured over as long as 10 to 20 years). So the up-front price has something of a sticker shock for many. Just remember that you are getting a guaranteed amount of long-term care coverage, and also a death benefit.

Here are pricing examples from Murray A. Gordon & Associates LTC (www.magaltc.com) for purchasing a hybrid/combo policy.

The first example is for a couple, both age 65, using the One America Asset Care product with a lump-sum single payment of $250,000.

They would get a long-term care benefit of $6,888 per month, per person, until they have exhausted the amount of the death benefit. At that point, they have a continuation of benefits rider, which extends their long-term care benefits at an even higher level of payout, reflecting the inflation protection. With this policy, there is a 30-day elimination period for home health care, and a 60-day elimination period for care in a facility. The care benefits include a 3% compound inflation adjustment.

There are no premium increases to worry about because they are covered by the single $250,000 deposit. But what if they never need care? In a traditional policy, all those premiums are down the drain if you die instantly of a heart attack or in a car crash. Combining it with life insurance, purchased with that same initial premium, is why I like combo LTC policies.

If one spouse dies, the survivor would not likely want to activate the death benefit, because now the survivor has an increased potential need to use the long-term care benefit. But assuming no care benefit was used—and no cash withdrawn—at the death of the second spouse, the beneficiaries would receive $229,628.

Now suppose the purchaser was a single buyer who never used the care portion of this policy. Then the death benefit would provide significant cash for the named beneficiary. Here’s the second example:

A man, age 50, deposits $100,000 into the Lincoln MoneyGuard II combo product. His initial LTC benefit is $6,296 per month, or a total of $488,662 per year in coverage for all types of long-term care costs (home, assisted living, adult day care, nursing home and hospice). The coverage will continue for a minimum of six years. And there is a 3% inflation increase in the benefits.

But if you don’t have that big of an up-front chunk of cash, consider paying a fixed and guaranteed premium for this same policy over 10 years. In that case, you would have to pay $12,819 a year—or $128,190 over 10 years—to get roughly the same benefits. That makes it more affordable from a cash flow point of view.

And if this single man dies two years after purchasing this policy, never using the long-term care coverage, his named beneficiary will receive a death benefit of $151,092.

Getting Started

If you truly want to avoid burdening your adult children with the cost and angst of your care, consider buying long-term care insurance. Even a little bit of insurance coverage could make a big difference for your entire family. You will need a specialist to advise you on this purchase.

Then, discuss your plans with your adult children, letting them know about your coverage. It will be a relief to them that you’ve lifted a multi-generational burden. That’s the Savage Truth. ?

Discussion

Joe from Colorado posted over 6 years ago:

Although not the final say on LTC insurance, here's a more balanced (and far less fear-inducing) view on the subject: https://www.retirementliving.com/pros-and-cons-of-long-term-care-insurance. I'm not sure if AAII has archives of articles covering this topic. A cursory search showed no articles on the topic. It would be helpful if AAII produced an LTC insurance article 1) providing clear and well-researched data on long-term care (e.g., percentage of people in LTC facilities, how long is a stay, true average costs for different kinds of care, etc.) and 2) comparing facility stay costs, at-home costs, and do-it-yourself costs.


Nick from Virginia posted over 6 years ago:

I found LTC to be a poor buy. The elimination period was excessive (90 days), the benefit limited and the cost went up every year. When I used the experience of my parents and their siblings to analyze the likelihood that LTC would pay off, there was only one case in 9 where the person would have survived thru the elimination period. I finally decided I was playing poker against an adversary who had unlimited funds and would keep raising the ante until I couldn't continue to play. Fortunately stopped playing early. Your milage may very, but I decided that a better solution was to invest the premiums that I would have paid to the insurance company.


Ken Kay from Florida posted over 6 years ago:

The six activities include maintaining continence. While six were mentioned, only five were listed.


Jean from AAII posted over 6 years ago:

Ken, thanks for letting us know and apologies for the error. We've added the 6th ADL in the box above.


Harry from Confusion posted over 6 years ago:

The fundamental problem with LTC is that for most people it should be "catastrophic" coverage, not "intended to be used." You can cover your own expenses for the average 3 years in a facility before dying. What is needed to drive down the cost is a much longer elimination period, such as 2-3 years. Kitces wrote about this years ago. Lobby Congress to change the rules to allow this.


RDL from Illinois posted over 6 years ago:

I'm trying to determine if I can be LTC self-insured. I've learned with medical, hospital, and dental care the cost of services is much less if you have insurance just because of the negotiated rates. Is that true of LTC as well? In other words, if I estimate LTC benefits of $100,000/year with insurance, is that comparable to $150,000/year without LTC?


RDL from Illinois posted over 6 years ago:

Adding to the previous comment: I would think that a person who paid cash for medical, hospital, dental services would play less because the provider wouldn't have to deal with forms, insurance companies, and delayed payment, but that is the opposite of reality. So, in trying to evaluate benefit of being LTC insurance covered do I have to factor in a penalty premium for being self insured and paying cash?


GARRY G from AZ posted over 6 years ago:

I've struggled with my own financial analysis of LTC insurance. The problem is that the cost is very high and the return is less than guaranteed. The insurance companies have the ability to raise the premiums, lower the benefits, make it difficult to submit claims, or simply go out of business. That uncertainty makes it very difficult to justify my purchasing LTC insurance.


FRED W from CA posted over 6 years ago:

Anyone who has researched LTC insurance knows that there are three groups of households: 1. Households with limited net worth (let’s say below $250,000) which would constitute 50%+ of America. These households can not afford LTC and should anticipate going on Medicaid if a senior in the HH needs extended LTC. 2. Households with net worth of $500,000 to $1,500,000. (The perfect target for LTC insurance purchasing). 3. Households with $2,000,000+ in net worth. (This group should consider self-insuring). As the “average” AAII portfolio is around $2 million, any article AAII publishes should discuss the pros and cons of self-insuring. I am 65 and made the decision to self insure about 5 years ago (after doing the research).


J D from FL posted over 6 years ago:

I support Fred W comments . My wife and I had LTC policies from NWML for 20 years but surrendered them last year. The significant premium increases in recent years combined with the growth in our portfolios and diminished years of life expectancy swung the analysis toward self insurance. We had retired early and the potential years of benefit were significant. Now we have shorter life expectancy years and greater certainty in our portfolio and ability to absorb the costs. Like fire insurance I don't feel bad that I paid for insurance and didn't need it but rather feel the self insurance is now a much better cost.


JOHN S from MI posted over 6 years ago:

This article prompted me to re-evaluate our decision to purchase LTC policies in 1999 at my age 59 and my spouse's age 57. I will detail that decision and experience below, but first want to acknowledge and amplify comments above from Harry and Fred W. Fred W is right that there are three net worth cohorts to consider: modest, comfortable, and wealthy. Modest must rely on Medicaid for lack of resources. Wealthy can self-insure. It's the comfortable who may need to, and in my opinion should, acquire LTC insurance. I suggest the range of net worth for that group should be $500K-$3MM, with limited policies at the lower end and more generous policies at the higher end. Comfort-care for the wealthy will be expensive, as I will illustrate. Harry is on target by reminding us that it is the catastrophic that we need to insure against, not first dollar coverage (although it does add up quickly at today's rates). Our policies have a 1 year elimination period for assisted living and skilled nursing care. More on that in a following note. Finally, appealing as the new hybrid policies may seem, ANY policy with a death benefit will incorporate an additional cost of mortality into the underwriting, adding to the cost of insurance, not reducing it. So, careful analysis of such hybrids is crucial.


JOHN S from MI posted over 6 years ago:

Continuing my previous note. My parents had net worth in excess of $3MM and self-insured. Alone after Mom died with little need for LTC, Dad needed 24 hour CNA and periodic RN assistance that made the 8 remaining years of his life truly comfortable. Today the equivalent care in our CCRC home would cost about $320K per year, on top of normal living expenses. To self-fund such comfort care alone, increasing at 5%, for ten years would require a dedicated initial fund of $4.3MM. In-home comfort care is clearly for the wealthy. For comparison, the cost of assisted living for ten years would require a fund ranging from $870K (level 1) to $1.3MM (level 3), and in skilled nursing $1.7MM, all including room and board. These scenarios could be self-funded by those in the comfortable range of net worth, meeting the needs of perhaps 85 percent of the aging. But ten years of coverage spread over two people is hardly a worst case scenario. We feared that worst case. So, we bought policies with a 1 year exclusion for skilled care (but only 10 days for in-home/community care), initially at $130/day, 5% compounded increase in benefit, and unlimited duration. Combined monthly premiums were $215, and over 21 years in force have risen to just under $800. We’ve spent nearly $93K for coverage, which now provides $362/day in benefits for our lifetimes with one (or possibly more than one)l exclusion for each of us. That’s less than one year of level 3 care in assisted living for one person at current rates. Even though we may never need care, we remain convinced that the peace of mind the insurance provides is well worth the cost.


S from ND posted over 6 years ago:

Hybrid/combo LTC and life insurance policies may be more well known now, but new they are not. My wife and I purchased such policies in 2008.


J M from NJ posted over 6 years ago:

I agree with the need for catastrophic long term care insurance coverage. I would like to see an article about the costs of long term care and the probabilities of needing it and for how long.


GARY M from WA posted over 6 years ago:

As an individual investor living primarily on 4% dividends it is clear our investment portfolio would also act as an end of life lump sum. This is easy to see now but several years ago, in the midst of several sensational articles about end of life costs, this was difficult to see as it is never certain what your portfolio will be worth until you get there. Articles like these suggest you should have some certainty at end of life so you are justified diverting thousands of dollars per year away from your retirement savings. Yet that savings provides multiple benefits, including an end of life lump sum. I would like to see AAII come back with a study on who should have this type of coverage based on forecast liquid assets at time of retirement, and at what point is it better to put savings in a 401K/Roth or buy this coverage.


DAVID R from FL posted over 6 years ago:

My main concern is the insurance companies. Have had LTC insurance for twenty years and now on the third company since the others thought it wasn't profitable enough after collecting years of premiums. Does not instill much confidence.


G V from DE posted over 6 years ago:

I agree that stand-alone LTC policies are a bad bet. When first offered, premiums were reasonable and benefits straightforward. Suddenly, in the 80's companies went bust because they failed to charge enough. They haven't gotten much better at pricing them. The hybrids, mostly from the two companies mentioned, are a far better alternative, especially if they can be funded so that money can be borrowed tax-free from the contracts. Today, as good a choice as the hybrids in most cases is the use of a carefully structured Indexed Universal Life contract with a generous LTC rider attached. In most cases, the death benefit will be larger and the flexibility much greater.


You need to log in as a registered AAII user before commenting.
Create an account

Log In

Get your free copy of our special report analyzing the tech stocks most likely to outperform the market.

Download the FREE Report Here: