Related
Financial Planning
The risk of high medical bills during retirement calls for a well-thought-out plan, especially at age 65, when you’re eligible for universal medical coverage under Medicare. Many crucial aspects of health insurance have the potential to save you a lot of money—or cost a lot if you aren’t paying attention.
by Steve Vernon | April 2019
This article is an excerpt from Vernon’s book “Retirement Game-Changers: Strategies for a Healthy, Financially Secure, and Fulfilling Long Life” (Rest-of-Life Communications, 2018).
Are you concerned about large medical bills that could wipe out your savings in retirement? If so, you’re not alone—this is a common fear that I hear expressed quite often.
The fact is, there’s a good reason to be concerned: If you’re like most people, the cost of health care is one item in your budget that will most likely increase substantially after you retire. Here’s why: According to the U.S. Department of Labor, on average, employers subsidize about 80% of the cost of medical insurance for their active employees and about two-thirds of the cost for families. But for most people, these subsidies will disappear when they retire. This represents a game-changing challenge that you need to address.

By making smart choices and putting plans in place to tackle your concerns, you can help alleviate your fears and feel better about your retirement years. The first step is to make sure you’ve developed well-thought-out, solid strategies for your income and expenses so you can make the magic formula for retirement income security work for you.
But that’s not enough: When it comes to your medical expenses, there’s more planning to do. High medical expenses can blow up your well-laid plans for managing your income and expenses. As a result, you’ll want to take some additional steps to protect yourself—and your spouse if you’re married—against the risk of high medical expenses.
Once you reach age 65, you are eligible for Medicare and you can’t be denied coverage for pre-existing conditions. Despite these benefits, managing your insurance coverage can still be complicated, and you’ll need to plan carefully to make every dollar count. It will be essential for you to make some key, informed choices as you approach your 65th birthday.
First, you’ll want to understand the four parts of Medicare:
Medicare doesn’t cover services for dental or vision care, unless it’s the result of a trauma or accident. Also, Medicare doesn’t cover the cost of hearing aids. You’ll want to make plans for paying these costs out of pocket or purchasing a policy that covers these expenses.
You can elect Original Medicare, where you enroll in Medicare Parts A and B and purchase a separate prescription drug plan under Part D. Here are a few key details:
There are gaps in Medicare coverage due to the significant deductibles and copayments, which can amount to thousands of dollars. As a result, most people who elect Original Medicare also buy a separate Medicare Supplement Insurance plan, also known as a Medigap plan, that pays for many of the expenses not covered by Medicare. You’ll pay a monthly premium for a Medigap plan, in addition to the Medicare Part B premium listed above. In 2017, costs for a separate Medigap plan ranged from $126 to $464 per month for men age 65, and from $118 to $464 for women of the same age, according to the National Medicare Supplement Price lndex.
One critical advantage of Original Medicare, when it’s supplemented by a Medigap plan, is that you can self-refer to health care providers who accept Medicare reimbursement. This gives you some degree of freedom when choosing your providers that you may not have with a Medicare Advantage plan. This might be important if you want to have the broadest possible access to medical professionals and specialists.
Medigap plans work alongside Medicare Parts A and B, paying for much of Medicare’s substantial deductibles and copayments. There are 10 standardized Medigap plans sold in most states, labeled with letters A through N. (Massachusetts, Minnesota and Wisconsin have a different standardization model.) Plan F provides the most comprehensive coverage, and as a result, it’s the most popular plan, selected by almost two-thirds of people who buy Medigap plans.
When you’re first eligible for Medicare Part B, you can’t be excluded from buying a Medigap plan for pre-existing conditions or be charged a higher premium. As long as you continue the coverage by paying the premiums, your policy is guaranteed renewable for the rest of your life.
If you want to change plans after you’re first eligible for Medicare, however, then insurance companies are allowed to apply medical underwriting. This means they can either exclude you altogether because of pre-existing conditions or charge you a higher premium if they deem you to be unhealthy. As a result, when you’re first eligible for Medicare, you’ll want to carefully consider the Medigap plan that will best suit your needs for the rest of your life. You may not get a “do-over” and be able to upgrade to a more generous policy in future years.
The cost of the premiums you’ll pay for a Medigap plan depend on the insurance company you select, your age, gender and where you live. There’s a very wide spread between the lowest and highest premium amounts, so it’s a good use of your time to shop around for the best plan.
Remember that Medicare doesn’t cover routine dental and vision care services. Medicare might pay for such services if you have an emergency or injury from a trauma. It also might pay for certain glaucoma screenings and cataract surgery.
Some insurance companies offer special coverage options to their Medigap plan members for routine dental and vision care, or they may offer insured members a discount program to help them save money on routine dental and vision care. You’ll want to investigate whether your Medigap plan covers these items. If it doesn’t, you may need to pay for these items out of pocket or look for stand-alone dental insurance or vision plans.
Medicare and Medigap plans might also cover hearing diagnostic tests if they’re medically necessary, but they won’t pay for the cost of hearing aids.
See the Helpful Resources box at the end of this article for links where you can learn more about Medigap plans.
Medicare Part D is a separate policy that pays for some or all of your costs for prescription drugs—these costs aren’t covered by Medicare’s other parts. Medicare mandates the features that must be offered in a basic Part D plan, although you can buy a policy with more generous features than the basic plan. Most, but not all, Medicare Advantage plans also cover prescription drug benefits, so if you participate in a Medicare Advantage plan, you’ll want to find out if you need to purchase a separate Part D plan.
Note that you can change your Part D plan in future years without needing to satisfy medical underwriting, if you want to upgrade to a more generous plan.
What follows are the features of a basic Part D prescription drug plan. Note that all figures are 2019 numbers.
Some drug plans may offer higher reimbursements if you use a network pharmacy; they may even require that you use a network pharmacy, so it’s important to find out if your favorite pharmacy is a preferred provider under the plan you buy.
Note that a Part D plan can provide more generous features than the basic plan described above, but you’ll spend more on monthly premiums. If you’re interested in expanded coverage, you’ll want to decide if the additional benefits would justify the extra premiums.
Medicare Part C, or Medicare Advantage, is an alternative to Original Medicare. Medicare Advantage plans are more like a Health Maintenance Organization (HMO) or Preferred Provider Organization (PPO), and they combine Parts A and B in order to provide you with integrated hospital, physician and outpatient coverage. Medicare Advantage plans have their own deductible and coinsurance schedules, so you don’t need to buy a separate Medigap policy, as you would with Original Medicare. By law, Medicare Advantage plans must provide the same services as Medicare Parts A and B, but these plans are in charge of how they’ll deliver medical services.
Medicare Advantage plans also usually cover Part D prescription drug benefits, and they may include extra coverage for special items such as vision care, dental care, hearing aids and/or wellness services. One goal of Medicare Advantage plans is to simplify your life by bundling health care services in a managed care environment. However, be aware that if you choose a Medicare Advantage plan, you might not be able to switch to a Medigap plan in the future, if your health or circumstances change.
In addition to your Part B premium, you’ll usually pay a monthly premium for the Medicare Advantage plan. In some instances, however, there’s no additional premium for so-called “zero premium plans.” In this case, you only need to pay your usual Part B premium.
For tips on choosing between a Medigap plan and a Medicare Advantage plan, see the box below.
Look beyond the premium amounts for Medicare Advantage plans: A trap for the unwary
Some people might be tempted to choose a Medicare Advantage plan that has a lower monthly premium than the combined amount of premiums for Medicare Part B, Medigap coverage and Part D prescription drug coverage. But before you select this alternative, do your homework and think long term, because you might not be eligible for a “do-over” in the future.
First, look beyond the premium amounts and estimate your out-of-pocket expenses with either approach. It’s possible that the copayments under a Medicare Advantage plan might outweigh the plan’s savings on premiums. You’ll also want to find out whether your current health care providers are in the network you’re thinking of choosing or whether you’ll be satisfied with the network’s providers.
More importantly, you’ll want to understand the implications of underwriting requirements that most Medigap plans apply. When you’re first eligible for Medicare, Medigap plans can’t exclude you for pre-existing conditions or charge higher premiums if you’re not healthy. But after the initial enrollment period, if you want to switch from a Medicare Advantage plan to Original Medicare during Medicare’s open enrollment period, in most cases, you won’t have a guaranteed right to get a Medigap policy. At that point, most Medigap plans are allowed to exclude you for pre-existing conditions or charge higher premiums. This can happen if you’re unhealthy according to their underwriting standards, which can be a potentially devastating disappointment.
The problems arise when people make shortsighted decisions when they’re healthy at the time they’re initially eligible. They might think, “I’m healthy now, and I don’t see my health care providers that often, so I’ll just elect the plan with the lowest monthly premium. If I develop a condition and want more freedom when choosing health care providers, I can always switch to Original Medicare and buy a Medigap plan.”
But that kind of thinking could be a big mistake. If you develop a serious medical condition, you may no longer meet the underwriting requirements of Medigap plans, and then you could be denied coverage. In this case, you’ll most likely be locked in to the providers in your Medicare Advantage plan’s network. If you want to use a specialist who isn’t in the network, you might be paying full cost for the care.
Note that in this example, you can always choose Original Medicare and self-refer to health care providers who accept Medicare. It’s just likely that you won’t be able to buy a Medigap policy that reimburses for Medicare’s deductibles and copayments, which can add up quickly if you have a serious medical condition.
As a result of the underwriting requirements and the ability of Medigap plans to deny coverage for pre-existing conditions, many people elect to participate in Original Medicare when they’re initially eligible for Medicare. They also buy separate Medigap and Part D policies in order to keep their options open in the years to come when selecting specialists and other health care providers. This may be an option you’ll want to consider if you think you’ll develop a serious or debilitating condition at some point in your life and might have trouble paying for Medicare’s deductibles and copayments.
The fact is, even if you’re healthy now, there’s a good chance you’ll incur a serious medical condition at some stage in your life; at that time, you might want to have the broadest freedom to pick health care providers.
Don’t get me wrong: I’m not trying to dissuade you from considering a Medicare Advantage plan. There are many such plans with robust networks of doctors, specialists and health care practitioners, particularly in large, urban areas. A well-chosen Medicare Advantage plan has the potential to save you significant amounts of money over your lifetime, and such a plan can greatly simplify your life when selecting health care professionals. Many Medicare Advantage plans have sound prevention and wellness programs that can help keep you fit.
You might have participated in a health care plan offered by a Medicare Advantage provider while you were working and developed trusted relationships with the health care practitioners in the network. In that case, it might make sense to continue with the Medicare Advantage plan offered by your health care provider.
I’m just advocating that you make your health insurance selections only after considering your possible needs for the rest of your life, and not just when you’re first eligible for Medicare and are still healthy.
Medicare Advantage plans typically restrict or encourage you to use the medical providers in the plan’s network. Here are the two most common types of Medicare Advantage plans:
HMO plans usually restrict care to providers within their network. If you choose otherwise, you’ll pay the full cost for providers outside the network, except possibly in the case of a medical emergency. In most cases, you’ll need to select a primary care doctor, and you’ll need a referral from that physician in order to see a specialist each time you need one.
PPO plans offer the best coverage and costs for in-network services, but they also allow physician choice by covering out-of-network care. However, you’ll pay higher out-of-pocket costs for out-of-network services. In most cases, you don’t need to select a primary care doctor, and you don’t need a referral to see a specialist.
In either case, you’ll want to check whether your doctors and specialists are in the network of the Medicare Advantage plan you’re considering. And you may want to consider possible future needs for specialists. You’ll also want to review and understand the plan’s premium amounts, deductibles and copayments and determine whether your Medicare Advantage plan pays for such items as dental care, vision care, hearing aids and wellness programs.
For more details regarding the various circumstances under which you can switch plans, see the links in the Helpful Resources box at the end of this article.
Whether you elect Original Medicare or a Medicare Advantage plan, you’ll want to make sure either you or your spouse have paid FICA taxes for at least 40 calendar quarters (10 years). This qualifies both of you for free Medicare Part A coverage.
If neither of you has paid FICA taxes for 40 quarters, you can still purchase Medicare Part A, but it will be costly. The premium in 2019 is $240 per month per person if you paid FICA taxes for 30 to 39 calendar quarters, and $437 per month per person if you paid FICA taxes for fewer than 30 quarters. If you’re close to these thresholds, you might consider continuing to work and paying FICA taxes until you reach these thresholds to either reduce or eliminate your Medicare Part A premiums.
There are many different rules and deadlines for enrolling in the various parts of Medicare, and enrollment dates can be different for each of Medicare’s four parts. For instance, if you start your Social Security income benefits before age 65, you’ll be automatically enrolled in Medicare Parts A and B to be effective at age 65, and you’ll receive your Medicare card three months before your 65th birthday. At that point, you’ll have the option to refuse Part B, since premiums are required, but that’s usually a bad idea. The only time it makes sense to delay signing up for Part B is when you’re getting coverage from another source, such as a health plan offered by your employer or your spouse’s employer.
If you aren’t covered by a medical plan at work and if you haven’t started your Social Security benefits by age 65, then it’s best if you enroll in Medicare Parts A, B and D no later than three months after your 65th birthday. This is necessary even if you continue to delay the start of your Social Security income benefits. If you don’t sign up for coverage before this deadline, coverage can be delayed and late penalties may apply.
Warning: If you delay signing up for Medicare Part B or Part D after you’re first eligible, Medicare applies a permanent penalty surcharge to your monthly premiums. The only exception is if you’re eligible for a special exemption, such as coverage from the Department of Veterans Affairs.
If you decide you’d rather be covered by a Medicare Advantage plan than be covered separately by Medicare Parts A and B, you’ll need to select and enroll in your Medicare Advantage plan no later than three months after your 65th birthday, though I always recommend doing it early so you don’t forget. Once again, if you don’t sign up for coverage before this deadline, coverage can be delayed and late penalties may apply. You can sign up as late as three months after your 65th birthday to avoid any penalties.
If you continue working beyond age 65 and are covered by your employer’s medical plan as an active employee, make sure you understand how that plan coordinates with Medicare. The best way to do this is to consult with your HR department or benefits administrator. One key reason to look into this is that there are different rules for employers with fewer than 20 employees compared to employers with 20 or more employees. It’s also important to note that many employer-sponsored plans require you to enroll in Medicare Part A but not Part B. You’ll also want to determine whether your employer’s plan covers prescription drugs; if so, you won’t need to sign up for Medicare Part D while you’re covered by your employer’s plan.
If you don’t enroll in Medicare Parts B and D because you’re covered by your employer’s plan while you’re working, the late enrollment penalties mentioned here won’t apply. To avoid a late penalty completely, however, you’ll generally need to enroll in Medicare Part B no more than eight months after you eventually retire. You’ll also need to buy a Medicare Part D plan within 63 days of your retirement date.
In most cases, you won’t want to elect a Medicare Advantage plan while you’re covered by your employer’s medical plan as an active employee since you’ll be duplicating coverage and wasting the premiums you’d have to pay for the Medicare Advantage plan.
Each year, during Medicare’s open enrollment period (from October 15 to December 7), you can switch from:
The problem arises when you want to switch from a Medicare Advantage plan to a Medigap plan that supplements traditional Medicare, or from one Medigap plan to another Medigap plan. Most states allow insurance companies to apply medical underwriting in this situation (Connecticut, Massachusetts and New York are the exceptions). If the insurance company finds you to be in poor health, it can increase your premiums or even deny coverage outright.
In limited circumstances, you’re sometimes allowed to switch out of a Medicare Advantage plan and into a Medigap plan without medical underwriting:
In addition to Medicare’s general open enrollment period in the fall of each year, there’s also another limited open enrollment period that runs from January 1 through March 31 of each year. During this period, you can:
For more details regarding the various circumstances under which you can switch plans, see the links in the Helpful Resources box at the end of this article.
The usual Medicare Part B premium covers about one-fourth of the costs of that coverage; the U.S. government subsidizes the rest of the cost. The government imposes higher premiums for high-income retirees, however, as one method to improve Medicare’s financing.
To determine if you’ll pay higher premiums for an upcoming calendar year, the Social Security Administration (SSA) looks back at your most recent available federal tax return, which is usually the tax year that’s two years before the year in which you’re paying Medicare premiums. The SSA uses a sliding scale to calculate the additional premiums you’ll pay, based on your modified adjusted gross income (MAGI). Your MAGI is your total adjusted gross income plus tax-exempt interest income.
Here are the basic guidelines: If you file taxes as married filing jointly and your MAGI is greater than $170,000, you’ll pay higher premiums for your Part B and Medicare prescription drug coverage. Also, if you file your taxes using single or head of household status and your MAGI is greater than $85,000, then you’ll also pay higher premiums.
Note that whether you’ll pay higher premiums is determined each year based on the look-back rule. So, it’s possible that you might pay higher premiums for a specific year but subsequently drop to the regular premium levels in the future, if your MAGI drops sufficiently.
If you end up having to pay a higher premium because of your high retirement income, you’ll want to factor those costs into your budget for living expenses. In limited circumstances, you can apply for a waiver of these additional costs. The most common situation that might prompt you to apply for a waiver is if your current income has dropped substantially because you retired compared to the look-back year, although there are other circumstances that apply as well.
For details on these rules, including a table that summarizes the additional premiums, see the link in the Helpful Resources box at the end of this article.
Be sure to carefully consider your own specific health care needs. Don’t blindly follow the advice of a well-intentioned family member or friend—their needs might be very different from yours. You might want to find experts who can help you sort through and choose the best option.
One good source is Medicare’s Star Rating System, which measures the performance of Medicare Advantage and Part D prescription drug plans.
Another option is to work with an insurance salesperson or website such as eHealthInsurance.com. They’ll earn a commission on the sale of insurance, which means they might be restricted in the plans they offer you, but they can help you pick the best plan for you among the plans they service.
You might also need to pay to hire a qualified, objective consultant to help you shop for a plan. This can not only help you save money, but it can help you choose the best plan for you. One note of caution: Make sure that any consultant you hire isn’t paid commissions from an insurance company or by selling your personal information.
The Helpful Resources box below identifies an independent consulting firm that I respect, helpful resources on Medicare’s website, as well as a website that contains a directory of Medigap insurance agents and two online health insurance agencies.
While it might be frustrating to spend this kind of time or money, remember: The medical procedures and drugs you’ll be covered for under the right plan may be what will keep you alive and healthy.
Helpful Resources
Information regarding when an insurance company can’t refuse to sell you a Medigap plan:
www.medicare.gov/find-a-plan/staticpages/learn/rights-and-protections.aspx
Medicare Advantage plans:
www.medicare.gov/sign-up-change-plans/types-of-medicare-health-plans/medicare-advantage-plans
Medicare’s costs and deductibles:
https://www.medicare.gov/your-medicare-costs/medicare-costs-at-a-glance
Medicare’s Plan Finder:
https://www.medicare.gov/find-a-plan/questions/home.aspx
Medicare’s Star Rating System:
https://www.medicare.gov/find-a-plan/results/planresults/planratings/compare-plan-ratings.aspx?PlanType=MAPD
Medigap plan overview:
https://www.medicare.gov/supplements-other-insurance/whats-medicare-supplement-insurance-medigap
Part D coverage for prescription drugs:
https://www.medicare.gov/drug-coverage-part-d
State health insurance assistance programs (SHIPs) that help you make decisions:
https://www.medicare.gov/Contacts/#resources/ships
Summary brochure:
https://www.medicare.gov/medicare-and-you
The American Association for Medicare Supplement Insurance offers helpful information about Medigap plans and a directory of insurance agents:
https://medicaresupp.org/medicare-supplement-insurance-costs
Health insurance rankings by state, including an interactive map:
https://wallethub.com/edu/states-with-best-health-care/23457/#mainfindings
Managing Retirement Decisions, maintained by the Society of Actuaries. “Securing Health Insurance for the Retirement Journey”
www.soa.org/files/research/research-pen-securing-health-insurance.pdf
Medicare’s Star Rating System:
www.ehealthmedicare.com/faq/what-are-medicare-plan-star-ratings
My Medicare Matters, a website maintained by the National Council on Aging, offers helpful resources.
National Association of Area Agencies on Aging often offers help navigating Medicare. This website can help you locate an agency near you:
https://www.n4a.org
Online insurance agencies that sell Medigap plans and contain useful information:
Sixty-Five Incorporated, a Medicare consulting firm that I respect . Its website contains a wealth of useful information:
https://www.65incorporated.com
U.S. News and World Report health rankings by state:
https://www.usnews.com/news/best-states/rankings/health-care
Financial Planning
Financial Planning
Insurance Products
Richard Abbott from Florida posted over 7 years ago:
John Hallquist from Tennessee posted over 7 years ago:
Marilyn Kinsey from MI posted over 7 years ago:
Terry Allen from Arizona posted over 7 years ago:
John Stoffels from MI posted over 7 years ago:
Donald Myers from AZ posted over 7 years ago:
Dave Swomley from FL posted over 7 years ago:
Jim from WA posted over 7 years ago:
Dave from AK posted over 7 years ago:
David from CO posted over 7 years ago:
Pedro Diaz from Florida posted over 7 years ago:
Jim from Florida posted over 7 years ago:
Gilbert from TN posted over 7 years ago:
You need to log in as a registered AAII user before commenting.
Log InCreate an account