Looking Beyond the S&P 500 as Rate Cuts Loom

Election years tend to be good for stocks. Hopefully, we will get more participation in any continuance of the current bull market. 

Charles Rotblut leads a class in AAII's new Essential Investing Video Course. Go to https://www.aaii.com/ves for more information and to subscribe.

Featured Tickers:

I reread my Editor’s Note from January 2023 while thinking about what to write for this issue’s opening remarks. One of things I wrote was, “Current expectations call for the Federal Reserve to pause its current rate hike cycle during the first half of 2023, according to the CME’s FedWatch Tool.”

As it turns out, the futures market wasn’t too far off with its forecast. The 25-basis-point (0.25%) hike announced on July 27, 2023, was the last increase of the current tightening cycle. The Federal Open Market Committee (FOMC) has since held its target for the federal funds rate steady.

So, what do traders expect to happen this year? As we went to press a few days before Christmas, the FedWatch Tool was signaling 89% probability of the Fed’s target rate being between 3.50% and 4.25% following its meeting on December 18, 2024. This is a large range. It suggests that between five and eight quarter-point cuts (0.25%) would be made at this year’s FOMC meetings, or a combination of some quarter-point and half-point (0.50%) cuts.

These odds are very much subject to change. What the Fed does will depend on both what happens with inflation and what happens with the economy. Everyone is hoping for the elusive economic soft landing to occur. Unfortunately, the track record of the U.S. economy avoiding a recession or a significant economic slowdown following an interest rate tightening cycle isn’t good. Fingers crossed.

This year, of course, is an election year. Election years tend to be good for stocks. Hopefully, we’ll get more participation in any continuance of the current bull market. Last year’s gains in the S&P 500 index were driven by the so-called Magnificent Seven large technology-related stocks.

Tech overall rebounded strongly in 2023 following a very lousy 2022. We saw this in the returns of many technology mutual funds and exchange-traded funds (ETFs). If you are interested in such funds, I encourage you to read Cynthia McLaughlin’s article. As you will see, there are significant differences between the various technology funds. Just as you shouldn’t judge a book by its cover, never judge an ETF by its name alone.

Back to the issue of participation, it wasn’t great last year. Through December 19, 2023, the S&P 500 rebounded by 24.2%. The S&P 500 Equal Weight index was up 11.2%. Same stocks, just different weightings. Put another way, the majority of stocks within the S&P 500 failed to keep pace with the index itself.

Still, you did not need to be in the Magnificent Seven to outperform. As John Bajkowski notes, 12 AAII Stock Screens outperformed the S&P 500 in 2023. Leading them was the Templeton screen, one of our guru screens. Among the traits it seeks out is a price-earnings (P/E) ratio below a stock’s five-year average. This relative value approach allowed Chipotle Mexican Grill Inc. (CMG) to pass the screen for most of 2023.

Among our factor screens, the Value on the Move PEG With Estimated Growth strategy was the 2023 leader. It seeks out stocks trading at discounted valuations relative to their projected earnings growth. United Rentals Inc. (URI), a stock held in the VMQ Stocks model portfolio, was one of the stocks passing this screen in December.

Both Chipotle and United Rentals have realized strong gains in 2023. Neither are like the Magnificent Seven stocks. I mention them because they are examples of how stock screens can lead you to stocks that may not be at the forefront of the headlines. Stock screens can also lead you to stocks you’ve never heard of with key traits you desire.

All AAII members have access to our 55 stock screens. I encourage you to use them if you’re going to actively invest in stocks. Our annual review of those AAII Stock Screens starts here.

Since each new year brings about resolutions, we have two articles for kicking off the year right. First, I offer suggestions for creating a one-page wealth-building plan for assets you plan to bequeath to your heirs. Second, Anine Sus discusses allocation and how to fill your portfolio in her latest installment of our Beginning Investor series.

On behalf of everyone at AAII, I wish you a happy, healthy and prosperous 2024,

Chuck Rotblut siganture image

Discussion

JOHN L from NJ posted over 2 years ago:

55 stock screens? Since only 12 beat the S&P 500 in 2023 or 22% that means that 78% fell short. Not great odds as it is much more likely you will pick a stock screen that under performs the S&P 500. And then there is the time and work involved in buying the stocks that passed the screen. Pro tip: Buy a cheap S&P 500 index fund and save the hassle.


BARRY J from TX posted over 2 years ago:

John, then again, we never know how bad (or possibly good) 12 of 55 or 22% (actually 21.8%) is without comparative data, do we? Data from TradingView can help us put the AAII 2023 screen performance that beat SPX’s 24% 2023 performance in perspective. TradingView data shows that since 1874-2023 (last 150 years) SPX finished > 20% 21 times out of 150 or 14.1% of the time, and SPX finished > 30% or more 7 more times or 7.4% of the time. Adding these data points, we can estimate that SPX finished > 20% 21.5% of the time. Thus, in 2023 AAII screens beat SPX’s 24% 21.8% of the time while SPX historically finished higher than 20% 21.5% of the time. Wait, there’s more. Although we cannot parse the 21 years in the 20%-29% decile band, using an estimated median for the 10 data points in that decile, we can estimate that these extra data points can only add to the AAII margin of victory and extrapolate that it is as many as 5 more years for a total estimated beat of 28.6% for AAII versus 21.5% for SPX. That’s 7 points or 1 football “touchdown.” Both Texas and Alabama fans would have collectively sold their mothers’ souls to the Devil last weekend for 7 points. That's the proximate magnitude of the AAII 2024 National stock screens championship. The rule is: The guy with comparative data usually wins.


JOHN L from NJ posted over 2 years ago:

Snake oil - Barry! A rotating group of stock screens that outperform does not make a consistent strategy versus the S&P 500. If you make enough predictions (55 screens now; use to be over 60) some of them by chance alone will be on top in the future. Which screen(s) will beat the S&P 500 over the next 20 years? The AAII needs to be more transparent and upfront about the results of the advice they peddle. For example: Educate the members by providing the annual performance achieved by the growing roster of newsletters. And more transparency concerning the shadow stock portfolio's performance. It hasn't had market beating returns in 15 years! Why? I don't see any proof that the current leadership of the AAII has the skill to beat the stock market in the long term. Many talk a good game. I won't believe until they show me their records!


DANIEL B from MI posted over 2 years ago:

I've got two Demographic Indicators, the 1st called the COAG Indicator, that predicts Inflation decades ahead, and the second, the MARS Indicator, that predicts demand for Stocks from new Retirement Savers. In analyzing your Model portfolio performance, I noted that your magnificent outperformance extended to January 2014, and hasn't been impressive since then. How interesting to note that my MARS Indicator topped between 97-01, and bottomed near 2014-15. It seems that your Model Portfolio does best in periods of demographic retrenchment, and one would have done best to switch to Aggressive Growth once the demographics turned positive. Did you know that the Nasdaq multiplied itself 88.5x between the '74 lows and the March 2000 high? All that while, a strong series of demographic surges were occurring. I see the secular Bull Market ending in one to two years based on the COAG and the MARS factors. If I receive support from AAII, I'll let the Group know when the End is Nigh!


You need to log in as a registered AAII user before commenting.
Create an account

Log In

Get your free copy of our special report analyzing the tech stocks most likely to outperform the market.

Download the FREE Report Here: