Increasing the Aftertax Returns on Your Portfolio

The two primary rules for reducing investing-related taxes are transacting less and holding less tax-friendly investments in tax-preferred accounts.

Charles Rotblut leads a class in AAII's new Essential Investing Video Course. Go to https://www.aaii.com/ves for more information and to subscribe.

  • The tax implications of capital gains, dividends and interest income in different account types to benefit your taxes
  • How higher investment income in one year can lead to higher Medicare premiums two years hence
  • Maximizing tax-efficiency through asset location, tax-cost ratios and charitable contribution options

Understanding the tax rules regarding capital gains, dividends, distributions and interest income can help increase your aftertax returns. Reducing turnover and making smart decisions about the types of accounts certain investments are held in—a concept known as asset location—will allow you to hold on to more of your investment gains and income.

Taxable Types of Investment Profits

Navigating the tax rules starts with understanding how they apply to the four primary ways investors realize profits from their portfolios.

Capital Gains

Capital gains are realized when you sell an investment at a higher price than what you acquired it at.

Short-term capital gains occur when an investment is sold within one year of purchasing it. They are taxed at ordinary (marginal) income rates for investments.

Investments held for longer than one year in a taxable account qualify for long-term capital gains rates. These rates are below the ordinary income rates.

For 2024, long-term capital gains rates are 0% for married couples filing joint returns with taxable income of $94,050 or less and single filers with taxable income of $47,025 or less. Married joint filers with income of $94,051 to $583,750 ($47,026 to $518,900 for singles) will pay a 15% tax rate. A 20% tax rate applies to incomes above $583,750 and $518,900, respectively.

These thresholds are inflation-adjusted. In 2025, there will be no long-term capital gains taxes owed on taxable income up to $96,700/$48,350 for married and single filers, respectively; 15% tax rate up to $600,050/$533,400 for married/single; and 20% for those with taxable income above those levels.

AAII’s My Portfolio allows you to track the capital gains and losses on your stocks, exchange-traded funds (ETFs) and mutual funds. Simply add your holdings, their purchase date(s) and the number of shares you own.

The main tab of My Portfolio is labeled “Portfolio.” In this tab’s menu is an option to see Gain/Loss Since Purchase (Figure 1). Clicking on it will show your current unrealized profits or losses. More than one lot can be added to My Portfolio if you purchased shares of the investment on different dates. To see the purchase dates or to add new lots, simply click on Modify. The default Modify view will show you the oldest purchase date and the average cost of your position. Clicking on the edit button will allow you to see additional lots.

Figure 1. Gain/Loss Tracking in AAII’s My Portfolio

My Portfolio helps AAII members to track gains and losses for stocks, mutual funds and exchange-traded funds (ETFs).

Figure 1  Gain/Loss Tracking in AAII’s My Portfolio

Source: AAII and QuoteMedia. Data as of 11/15/2024.

Note that the net capital gains from selling collectibles (such as coins or art) are taxed at a maximum 28% rate.

Capital gains taxes can be minimized by limiting turnover in taxable accounts, holding investments for over one year in taxable accounts, and/or using tax-advantaged accounts—such as individual retirement accounts (IRAs)—for strategies or funds with higher levels of turnover.

Dividends

Dividends are categorized as either qualified or nonqualified.

Qualified dividends are taxed at the same favorable rates as long-term capital gains rates if holding period requirements are met. A stock must be owned for at least 61 consecutive days during a 121-day period beginning 60 days before the ex-dividend date. Preferred stocks must be held for 91 days during the 181-day period that began 90 days before the ex-dividend date. Failure to meet these holding periods will result in the dividend being taxed at the higher ordinary income rates.

Nonqualified dividends are taxed as ordinary income. Most companies pay qualified dividends; contact the company’s investor relations department if you are unsure.

Distributions

Distributions are other payments of income to shareholders. Real estate investment trusts (REITs) make distributions that are taxable as ordinary income rates. Master limited partnerships (MLPs) often include a return of capital in their distributions. Whenever capital is returned, the payment decreases your cost basis in the investment. The return of capital is not taxable as long as your cost basis remains above $0, though your future taxable gains will be larger.

Mutual funds, ETFs and closed-end funds may distribute capital gains, qualified dividends, nonqualified dividends, return of capital and/or interest income. Taxable distributions can occur even when a fund’s calendar-year returns are negative.

The tax-cost ratio indicates how tax-efficient or inefficient a fund has been. This ratio measures how much a fund’s annualized return is reduced by the taxes paid on distributions, assuming the maximum marginal tax rate. The lower the ratio, the more tax-efficient the fund.

The tax-cost ratio for a specific ETF or mutual fund can be viewed on AAII’s Evaluator pages. To access them, just type the fund’s name or ticker symbol into the search box located at the top of most pages on AAII.com. The ratio is also included in AAII’s Mutual Fund and ETF Guides. Furthermore, A+ Investor and AAII Platinum subscribers can use the Mutual Fund and ETF Screeners to filter for ETFs and mutual funds with low tax-cost ratios.

Interest Income

Interest income is typically realized from bonds, money market funds and interest-bearing accounts. Interest income can be either taxable or tax-exempt.

Interest received from corporate bonds and most interest-bearing accounts is taxable at ordinary income rates. Interest (coupon) payments from Treasury bonds are generally taxable at the federal level at ordinary income rates but exempt from state taxes.

Municipal bond interest is exempt from federal taxes. It is also exempt from state taxes depending on the locale of the issuer and the taxpayer.

Managing the Tax Implications of Investing

A simple rule to understand is that when holding periods for assets (including stocks, bonds and funds) are not met, any gains realized will be taxed at the ordinary marginal tax rates. The same rule applies to dividends when the 60-day or 90-day holding periods are not met.

Long-term capital gains and qualified dividends are taxed under the more favorable capital gains rates (which can be as low as 0%). Municipal bond interest is also exempt from federal and state taxes (depending on locale). For this reason, realizing long-term gains and receiving qualified dividend income and municipal bond interest in taxable accounts is preferred. All other taxable income is better realized in tax-preferred accounts like IRAs and Roth IRAs. (Those in the higher marginal brackets may find it advantageous to hold dividend stocks in tax-preferred accounts.)

The Net Investment Income Tax

The 3.8% net investment income (NII) tax applies to interest, dividends, capital gains, rental and royalty income, and nonqualified annuities, among other investment-related income realized in taxable accounts.

The NII tax is levied on joint filers with modified adjusted gross income (MAGI) above $250,000 and single filers with MAGI above $200,000. Distributions from tax-deferred accounts like traditional IRAs are included in the calculation of MAGI.

Social Security Benefits and Medicare Premiums

Up to 85% of Social Security benefits may be taxed if your combined income—MAGI plus half of your Social Security benefits—exceeds certain thresholds. One-half of municipal bond interest realized in taxable accounts is included in the calculation of combined income.

Investment income, including tax-exempt bond interest, is also factored into Medicare’s income-related monthly adjustment amount (IRMAA). Higher investment income in one calendar year can lead to higher Medicare Parts B and D premiums two years later.

Taxable distributions from IRAs and other tax-preferred accounts also increase your current combined income as well as raise your Medicare premiums two years out.

Reducing Investing-Related Taxes

The two primary rules for reducing investing-related taxes are transacting less and holding less tax-friendly investments in tax-preferred accounts (IRAs, Roth IRAs, etc.).

Other options include using capital losses to offset capital gains, donating appreciated assets from taxable accounts to charity and making Roth IRA conversions.

Discussion

JOHN L from NJ posted over 1 year ago:

In summary, taxable accounts should have tax efficient holdings such as individual stocks and ETFs. Capital gains will only be recognized when you sell the stock or ETF. This gives you control over income recognition. A valuable option when trying to avoid higher tax brackets or keep income below an IRMAA threshold. Should you die with these investments; the cost basis will step up at your death and your heirs will not pay any capital gains on the stocks or ETFs. Dividends will be taxed for ETFs and individual stocks in taxable accounts. However, as an additional bonus, if you meet the holding period requirement the dividends will be taxed at the lower capital gains rates. Tax inefficient holdings such as mutual funds, bonds, and REITS should be kept in IRAs. Preferably Roth IRAs.


ROBERT A from NC posted over 1 year ago:

Young investors: Do your own tax returns! By doing your own returns, you necessarily learn about the tax code and can apply it to your EXCELLENT long-term benefit. Most tax preparers don't have the time (unless you pay them a boatload of your hard-earned income) to coach you on all the tax-saving strategies available. In the long run, ignorance of the tax code will cost you GREATLY! (I'd also encourage young people to learn to prepare their taxes the old-fashioned way, with pencil and paper. TurboTax is okay, but using it does not provide the depth of understanding achievable through manual preparation.) Doing your own returns takes time, but that is time well invested!


BARRY J from TX posted over 1 year ago:

I estimate my tax liabilities as I go. I have done this for many years. I diligently try to learn and follow the rules as they change YOY, but I always have a CPA file our returns. The costs in penalties and aggravation for me screwing up a simple calculation or omitting a liability is just too great not to have a CPA check my homework. Charles, I appreciate AAII staff efforts and fees AAII expends to assist members in understanding and preparing for estimating and reducing tax implications of our investment actions. I rely on the AAII Annual Tax Update publication to help me anticipate and verify the amounts and percentages of potential tax liabilities. I estimate that just plugging in these amounts to estimate tax liabilities saves 1-2 hours of my CPA's billable time by reducing the billable hours his firm has to devote to figuring out what new bonehead actions I have made this year ... again. This is one more example of the value of a lifetime AAII membership. By maintaining my CPA's goodwill in these ways, I am able to get strokes in our Nassaus and that provides me a reasonable chance to get some of my fees back. Somehow accountants play more golf than I do and I am retired. Go figure. Ooops! Forget that, figuring runs up this bill. That's why I keep score. Regards.


THOMAS S from OR posted over 1 year ago:

I'll echo a strong agreement with both Robert A & Barry J. I find the AAII annual tax update a great starting point for tax-related changes each year. I haven't submitted a paper return since my first use of Turbo Tax for TY1997, but I supplement the software and my tax code understanding by spending several hours each year reading IRS publications. Doing my own taxes keeps the details of tax code implications on my investing decisions top of mind year-round, and that's a money-saving benefit. I don't have an accountant look over my work, and, yes, I've made some boneheaded mistakes, but nothing that was that costly. Besides, the lessons learned just make a deeper impact when there is some cost involved. I don't regret the thousands I spent on medical school, nor do I regret any of the costly mistakes I've made in my investing avocation. That's the cost of education, and I think it's been worth it. Wow, I guess that's why friends consider me an optimist. These rose-colored glasses really do work well.


ROBERT A from NC posted over 1 year ago:

Addendum to my earlier post: I prepare my returns manually, but then I use TurboTax as a double-check and to e-file. That might seem like a lot of work, but it's fun to a boring guy like me. I agree with Thomas S that "Doing my own taxes keeps the details of tax code implications on my investing decisions top of mind year-round, and that's a money-saving benefit" and that the educational cost of mistakes is usually worth it.


You need to log in as a registered AAII user before commenting.
Create an account

Log In

Get your free copy of our special report analyzing the tech stocks most likely to outperform the market.

Download the FREE Report Here: