AAII Investor Update: Analysts Pressured to be Positive

Thursday, November 17, 2011
Charles Rotblut, CFA
AAII Journal Editor

AAII Resources

Standard & Poor’s Reports
Access research reports from S&P for many stocks, including those held in the Model Shadow Stock portfolio.

Model Portfolios
These real-world portfolios have solid performance track records and are a great educational tool for our members.

AAII Model Portfolio October Return 1-Year Return
Shadow Stock



Mutual Fund






AAII Discussion Boards
Do you look at analyst research and, if so, how do you use it?

Most Popular AAII Articles

  1. “TIPS and the Nature of Inflation Protection”
  2. “Model Mutual Fund and ETF Portfolios: Waiting for Value and Small-Cap to Improve”
  3. “Rules-Based Investing Essential for Stock Investors”
order AAII Conference audio

‘Ban the analysts!’

This is what European Union commissioner Michel Barnier recently suggested. Barnier proposed banning credit agencies from rating the sovereign debt of countries undergoing bailouts. The commissioner was pressured into withdrawing his proposal for a ban, though he is still pushing for other reforms.

Barnier’s suggestion was nothing new. Analysts, covering both credit and equity securities, have long been under pressure to be positive. At a time when confidence in certain European countries to repay their debts is faltering, it is understandable that the credit agencies would be a target of backlash. Barnier had hoped that by banning rating agencies he could restore faith in problematic European countries.

The problem is not so much with Barnier’s suggestion as with the systemic pressure that analysts are under. Banking analyst Mike Mayo openly discussed how his negative comments on financial companies have caused problems throughout his career in his book “Exile on Wall Street” (John Wiley & Sons, 2011). Government officials and regulators are often quick to attack analysts who lower their credit ratings; corporate executives tend to be more subtle, but they still can and do retaliate. An analyst can see his access to executives limited and encounter other forms of pressure. The fact that the number of “buy” ratings far exceeds the number of “sell” ratings is no accident.

Analysts are not completely innocent, either. They are subject to the same behavioral errors that the rest of us are. Analysts get close to the government entities and companies under their coverage, making analysts more sympathetic to the securities they are covering. (Not to mention making it easier to miss the forest for all the trees.) Analysts also succumb to herd behavior, meaning they are unlikely to create a forecast or reach a conclusion that is significantly different from that of their peers.

This is not to say that analyst research is universally bad. Quite the contrary, I think it has value when used properly.

What should you specifically look for? First, determine the direction of the change in rating and tone of the commentary. Are the majority of analysts more optimistic or pessimistic than they have been previously? (It is easier to find the rating than the actual commentary.) Second, for stocks, pay attention to the change in earning estimates. Though stock analysts are usually wrong when forecasting actual profits, they tend to be fairly good about predicting whether earnings will be better or worse than previously thought. (Plus, earnings estimates are easy to find.) Finally, if you can access a research report, read it to see if the analyst points out something you missed in your analysis. You don’t have to agree with the analyst’s conclusion, but you should understand why your opinion differs. (Many brokerage websites make research reports available to their clients.)

Analyst Research on AAII.com

Analyst research on stocks can be found on AAII.com. Consensus brokerage ratings (buy, hold and sell) and earnings estimates can be accessed from a stock’s quote page. Simply go to the AAII.com home page and enter a ticker to call up the quote page. Then click on either the ‘Analyst’ or
the ‘Earnings’ tab.

Standard & Poor’s research reports are also available in the Investing section of our website.

Do you look at analyst research and, if so, how do you use it? Tell us on the AAII.com Discussion Boards.

Investor Conference Audio Now Available

Audio recordings of more than 50 presentations from last week’s Investor Conference can now be listened to, or downloaded, from AAII.com. In addition, you can also download the presenter’s slides.

I enjoyed meeting many of you at our Conference last week, and I hope you found the speakers to be as valuable as I did.

Model Portfolios Updated on AAII.com

After several months of negative returns for the stock markets, October finished as one of the strongest months for quite some time. Caution still remains over the European debt crisis, but investors are hopeful that domestic unemployment is on the downswing. All three model portfolios finished the month of October with strong gains.

The Model Shadow Stock Portfolio gained 16.3% for the month, its best month since April of 2009. The Model Shadow Stock Portfolio beat both the Vanguard Small Cap fund (NAESX), which gained 15.3%, and the DFA US Micro Cap fund (DFSCX), which gained 15.4%. For the year, the Shadow Stock Portfolio is almost back to even, down 0.8%, while the Vanguard Small Cap fund is down 2.6% and the DFA US Micro Cap fund is down 3.5%. Smaller-capitalization stocks remain weak for the year but had a strong bounce-back during the month of October.

The Model Mutual Fund Portfolio was up 11.8% for the month, which is again the best month since April of 2009. This compares to the Vanguard Total Stock Market fund (VTSMX), which gained 11.5%. Year-to-date (through October 31), the Model Mutual Fund Portfolio is down 2.3%, while the Vanguard Total Stock Market fund is up 0.5%;.

The Model ETF Portfolio gained 13.0%, again, its strongest month since April of 2009. The 80% SPDR S&P 500 ETF (SPY) and 20% iShares MSCI EAFE Index ETF (EFA) benchmark gained 10.6%. Year-to-date, the Model ETF Portfolio is down 3.8%, while its benchmark is down 0.4%.

There were no transactions made in any of the model portfolios for the month of October.

The Week Ahead

The U.S. financial markets will be closed on Thursday in observance of Thanksgiving Day. The U.S. equity markets will close early on Friday, at 1:00 p.m. ET.

Dow component Hewlett-Packard (HPQ) will report earnings on Monday. Joining the company will be nine other S&P 500 members including Tyson Foods (TSN) on Monday, Campbell Soup (CPB) and Hormel Foods (HRL) on Tuesday, and Deere & Company (DE) on Wednesday.

The week’s first economic report will be October existing home sales on Monday. Tuesday will feature the first revision to third-quarter GDP estimates. October durable goods orders, October personal income and spending, the final November University of Michigan consumer confidence survey and the minutes from November Federal Open Market Committee will be published on Wednesday.

Atlanta Federal Reserve Bank President Dennis Lockhart will speak publicly on Monday.

AAII Sentiment Survey

Sentiment Survey

This week’s AAII Sentiment Survey results:
  Bullish: 41.9%, down 2.8 points
  Neutral: 27.0%, down 3.7 points
  Bearish: 31.0%, up 6.5 points

Long-term averages:
  Bullish: 39%
  Neutral: 31%
  Bearish: 30%

Take the AAII Sentiment Survey »

Bullish sentiment, expectations that stock prices will rise over the next six months, declined 2.8 percentage points, to 41.9%. Nonetheless, this was the first time optimism has stayed above 40% for four consecutive weeks since February 2011. The historical average is 39%.

Neutral sentiment, expectations that stock prices will be essentially unchanged over the next six months, fell 3.7 percentage points to 27.0%. This is the 17th time in the past 18 weeks that neutral sentiment has been below its historical average of 31%.

Bearish sentiment, expectations that stock prices will fall over the next six months, rebounded by 6.5 percentage points to 31.0%. This was the first time in four weeks that pessimism has been above its historical average of 30%.

AAII members continue to be more upbeat about the six-month direction of stocks prices than they were in August and September. Optimism remains cautious, however, as evidenced by the bullish sentiment reading. The slow level of U.S. economic growth, Europe’s sovereign debt crisis, Washington politics and the market’s daily volatility are combining to keep confidence at historically modest levels, and the nerves of some individual investors are frayed.

This week’s special question asked AAII members what sectors and industries they currently like. Oil and technology tied as the favorites. Health care and utilities tied for second, followed by consumer staples. When the same question was asked in August, members said they liked energy, basic materials/commodities, health care, utilities and technology.

Are you bullish, bearish or neutral? Take the AAII Sentiment Survey and tell us.

Have a Happy Thanksgiving,

Charles Rotblut, CFA
AAII Journal Editor